Showing posts with label Reagan-Obama Jobs Gap. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reagan-Obama Jobs Gap. Show all posts

Sunday, July 12, 2015

Job Growth Still Weak, Like the Recovery


Last week brought more mediocre news about the Nation's economy. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics ("BLS"), the economy added a seasonally-adjusted 223,000 jobs in June, 2015, the 73rd month of this economic recovery.  (The current recovery started in June, 2009.)   The BLS also revised downward the employment growth figures for April and March.   These results follow prior reports that the economy grew a mere 0.2 percent in the first quarter of 2015, "nearly grinding to a halt," as a report in the Washington Post put it.

The New York Times, for instance, claims these latest employment figures show "healthy" job growth, consistent with its prior claim that May job growth (now revised downward) was "strong." (To be fair, another Times analyst opines that the June numbers are "weaker than they look.")  Analysis of the historical record, particularly that of the nation's recovery from the 1981-82 recession, suggests that June job growth, like that throughout this recovery, was quite disappointing.

As noted above, June, 2015 is the 73rd month of the recovery that began in June, 2009.  By comparison, the so-called Reagan recovery began in November, 1982.  The 73rd month of that recovery, November, 1988, saw job growth of 339,000, about 52 percent larger than that of June 2015.  (Go to this website and insert the appropriate dates to generate these figures.)    Moreover, this 52 percent figure actually understates the gap between job growth in these two months. After all, the workforce and thus total employment was significantly smaller (106,277,000) in October, 1988 than it was this most recent May (141,619,000).   Hence, employment grew at a rate of just over three tenths of one percent in November 1988 compared to the prior month's level, slightly more than double the June 2015 rate of growth. The significant disparity between these two months is not an anomaly: total employment increased by nearly nine tenths of one percent in the combined months of September, October and November of 1988, compared to less than five tenths of one percent in April, May and June 2015.     Previous posts on this blog have reached similar conclusions about the relative strength of employment growth during the Reagan recovery and the Obama recovery.  (See here and here, for instance.).  The left-leaning Center for American Progress apparently agrees.  In a recent essay about the state of the employment market, the CAP concludes that: "job growth remains weak compared to previous recessions."  (By "previous recessions" the essay apparently means "recoveries from previous recessions."). 

Such disappointing employment growth should not be surprising, given the slow pace of economic growth during this recovery which, as noted above, began in June, 2009.  Here are the annual rates of GDP growth for the last five years, according to the World Bank, beginning with 2010, the first full year of recovery from this most recent recession:


2010:   2.5

2011:   1.6

2012:   2.3

2013:   2.2

2014:   2.4

Thus, annual GDP growth averaged 2.2 percent during this period.

Here, by contrast, are the annual rates of GDP growth during the Reagan recovery, beginning with 1983, the first full year of recovery from this recession:

1983:  4.6

1984:  7.3

1985:  4.2

1986:  3.5

1987:  3.5

1988:  4.2

Annual GDP growth averaged 4.6 percent during this period, more than twice that during the Obama recovery.  (Note that excluding the 1983 figure results in the same rate of average annual GDP growth, namely, 4.6 percent). 

Economists and others will no doubt spend decades debating why the Obama recovery is so weak.  However, there can be no doubt that, judged by the rate of economic expansion and employment growth, this recovery is a disappointment that still leaves millions of Americans without the economic opportunities they deserve.   


Friday, October 5, 2012

Obama "Recovery" Still Fizzling

This morning the Labor Department reported that the economy added a mere 114,000 jobs in September.  (See here for the story)  That's less than half the number of jobs the economy added in September, 1984, during the Reagan Recovery, when employment increased by 240,000.  (Go to this website and insert the appropriate dates to obtain the September, 1984 figures.)    This poor showing is no surprise, given that real GDP is growing at a snail's pace: annual rates of 2.0 percent and 1.3 percent in the first and second quarters of 2012, respectively (see this Department of Labor Press Release for the GDP figures), compared to real economic growth of 6.8 percent in 1984.

Moreover, as previously explained on this blog with respect to prior months (see also here and here), the actual jobs gap between the Reagan and Obama recoveries for this most recent month is even larger than these data suggest.  After all, the 1984 labor force was significantly smaller than it is today, with the result that the addition of 240,000 new jobs reflected a larger rate of employment growth than would a similar increase today.  Thus, to replicate the September, 1984 rate of job grow, the economy should have created over 300,000 jobs in September, 2012.  (See here for an example of such a calculation in a prior month.)  Thus, the jobs gap between the Obama and Reagan recoveries, which stood at 1.7 million for the months of April through August, is still growing.

Friday, September 7, 2012

August Jobs Report Disappoints

This morning brought another disappointing jobs report from the Department of Labor.  According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the economy added a mere 96,000 jobs in August.  By contrast, in August of 1984, during the Reagan Recovery, the economy added 241,000 new jobs.  (Go to this website and insert the appropriate dates to locate this figure.)   As previously explained on this blog, the labor force was much smaller during the Reagan Recovery.    Thus, in order to replicate the rate of job growth the country experienced in August, 1984, the economy should have created over 300,000 new jobs in August, 2012.  In short, the Obama "recovery" is still sputtering, and the Reagan-Obama jobs gap is still growing.  To be precise, for the months of April, 2012 through August, 2012, the Reagan-Obama jobs gap stands at 1.7 million.  (See here for a calculation of the April through July gap).

The President and his allies often speak of the need to share the fruits of prosperity.  Many Americans likely wonder "what prosperity?"

Friday, August 3, 2012

Reagan-Obama Jobs Gap Still Growing

Today's jobs report reconfirms that the current economic recovery is far weaker than the recovery from the deep recession of 1981-82, the closest parallel to the recent "Great Recession" of 2008-2009. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the economy added just 163,000 jobs in July. By contrast, in July, 1984, well into the Reagan recovery, the economy added nearly twice as many jobs --- 312,000 to be exact. (Go to this website and insert the appropriate month to confirm this figure.) Moreover, as previously explained on this blog, these figures actually understate the relative strength of the Reagan and Obama recoveries. After all, the current civilian workforce of 155,013,000 (the July, 2012 figure) is much larger than it was in 1984, when the figure stood at 113,500,000. (The exact figure for July, 1984, is currently not available on the BLS website.)   Thus, in order to replicate the rate of employment growth that occurred in July, 1984, the economy would have to create 426,000 jobs, instead of the 163,000 actually created in July.  As a result, the real gap between July, 1984 and July, 2012 employment growth is 263,000  jobs, bringing the actual gap between the last four months of the Reagan recovery and the last four months of the Obama recovery to nearly 1.5 million jobs.  (As explained in this post, the real gap between the second quarter of the 1984 Reagan recovery and the second quarter of the 2012 Obama recovery was 1,205, 415 jobs.)

The American people deserve a stronger recovery.